Podcast: Law & Policy Co-Editor Colin Scott and author Hadar Aviram on Law and Disobedience in Israeli Courts
Posted by lawpol on August 27, 2008
Law & Policy Co-Editor Colin Scott and author Hadar Aviram discuss the wider social and theoretical implications of Professor Aviram’s recent article, “How Law Thinks of Disobedience: Perceiving and Addressing Desertion and Conscientious Objection in Israeli Military Courts,” Law & Policy 30(3): 277-305. The podcast conversation is available HERE.
Here is the abstract from the article:
The study transcends the dichotomy “law in the books”/”law in action” by taking law’s knowledge-production mechanisms seriously. It examines how the Israeli military justice system perceives and addresses disobedience toward the mandatory military service duty by deserters and conscientious objectors. Both groups resist the military service ethos but differ in the offenders’ demographics and motivations. The findings show how law co-opts the socio-political problems, assimilates them, and transforms them to narrow its framework. The legal system can be cognitively open to external frameworks introduced by powerful and resourceful defendants; it remains, however, normatively closed to alternative rules and perspectives.
